Our Pick: Kelty

Check price →

Best 2-Person Backpacking Tents Under $300 (2026)

Five two-person tents from $150 to $229 that still behave like backpacking tents: listed weights from about 3.5 lb to 5 lb 14 oz, floors from 29 to 32 sq ft, aluminum poles on every one. The Kelty Grand Mesa 2 is our pick at about $150; the Marmot Crane Creek 2P is the one to buy if two doors matter more than a pound.

By The WorldHike Gear Desk · ~14 min read · Updated 2026-08-23

Our PickKelty Grand Mesa 2

Kelty Grand Mesa 2

Kelty

30 sq ft, a 44 in peak, and 4 lb 1 oz trail weight for about $150 from a 70-year tent maker.

Check price

★ Our Top Pick

Kelty Grand Mesa 2

Kelty Grand Mesa 2

30 sq ft, a 44 in peak, and 4 lb 1 oz trail weight for about $150 from a 70-year tent maker.

about $1504.5

Not sure yet? Compare all 5 picks below ↓

Short answer: under $300, buy the Kelty Grand Mesa 2 (about $150 at time of writing). It lists 4 lb 1 oz trail and 4 lb 7 oz packed, a 30 sq ft floor (85 x 57 in), a 44 in peak, aluminum poles, a single door with a vestibule, and a freestanding pitch, from a brand that has made backpacking tents since the 1950s. If you need two doors and two vestibules, because two people share it and neither wants to climb over the other at 2 a.m., buy the Marmot Crane Creek 2P (about $229): 32 sq ft, 43 in peak, 7000-series aluminum, and a listed 2,400 g (about 5 lb 5 oz). If you want the lightest tent in the band, the Naturehike Cloud Up Pro 2 (about $159) lists in the 3.5 to 4 lb range with a two-layer build, and it is the one to carry on longer trips.

Here is what $150 to $230 buys and does not buy. It buys aluminum poles, taped seams, a full rain fly, and a packable form factor on every tent here; none of these is a car-camping dome in disguise. It does not buy weight. The flagship tents in our main guide list 2 lb 11 oz to 3 lb 5 oz trail weight; these list 3.5 to 5 lb 14 oz. The difference is fabric denier (68D and 75D polyester here against 15D to 20D nylon), pole count, and detailing. Split between two people, a 5 lb tent is 2.5 lb each, which is a rational weekend load. Carried solo on a 20-mile day it is not, and that is the cut line: this guide is for pairs and for hikers whose trips are short enough that a pound matters less than $400.

Disclosure: no brand paid for a place here. Links go to Amazon, where we earn a commission if you buy. It does not change the order.

The short version

  • Our pick: Kelty Grand Mesa 2, about $150. Listed 4 lb 1 oz trail / 4 lb 7 oz packed, 30 sq ft (85 x 57 in), 44 in peak, 68D polyester, aluminum poles, one door, one vestibule, freestanding. Best floor-per-dollar in the band.
  • Best two-door: Marmot Crane Creek 2P, about $229. Listed 32 sq ft (86 x 50 in), 43 in peak, two D-doors and two vestibules, 7000-series aluminum, seam-taped polyester; Amazon lists 2,400 g (about 5 lb 5 oz).
  • Lightest: Naturehike Cloud Up Pro 2, about $159. Listed 3.5 to 4 lb packed depending on version, 20D two-layer, freestanding body with a staked vestibule, one door. Tier B brand, judged and kept.
  • Fastest pitch: Kelty Late Start 2, about $160. Listed 4 lb 8 oz packed, about 29 sq ft, 40 in peak, pre-bent poles, one door. The tent for after-work departures.
  • Toughest: The North Face Stormbreak 2, about $220. Listed 5 lb 14.2 oz total / 5 lb 5 oz trail, 30.56 sq ft (87 x 50 in), 43 in peak, 75D polyester throughout, two doors. Heavy and built like it.
  • Just over the line: MSR Elixir 2, about $340. The step-up most people consider; we say when the extra $110 is worth it below.
  • None of these is a car-camping tent. All have aluminum poles, taped seams, and full flies. The budget tents to avoid are described in the skip list.
TentBest forListed weightFloorPeakDoorsFabricPrice (Aug 2026)
Kelty Grand Mesa 2Our Pick4 lb 1 oz trail / 4 lb 7 oz packed30 sq ft (85 x 57 in)44 in1 + 1 vestibule68D polyesterabout $150
Marmot Crane Creek 2PBest two-door2,400 g (about 5 lb 5 oz), Amazon listing32 sq ft (86 x 50 in)43 in2 + 2 vestibulesSeam-taped polyesterabout $229
Naturehike Cloud Up Pro 2Lightestabout 3.5 to 4 lb packed (by version)about 83 x 49 inabout 40 in1 + staked vestibule20D nylon, two-layerabout $159
Kelty Late Start 2Fastest pitch4 lb 8 oz packedabout 29 sq ft40 in1 + 1 vestibulePolyesterabout $160
The North Face Stormbreak 2Toughest5 lb 5 oz trail / 5 lb 14.2 oz total30.56 sq ft (87 x 50 in)43 in2 + 2 vestibules75D polyesterabout $220

Makers' listed specs from the live Amazon listings, August 2026. Trail weight = body, fly, poles; packed adds stakes and sacks. Where a maker lists only one figure, the column says which. Prices are live Amazon figures at time of writing.

01 · Best Overall Under $300

Our Pick
Kelty Grand Mesa 2

Kelty Grand Mesa 2

4.5about $150

30 sq ft, a 44 in peak, and 4 lb 1 oz trail weight for about $150 from a 70-year tent maker.

Field check: Listed 4 lb 1 oz trail / 4 lb 7 oz packed · 30 sq ft (85 x 57 in) · 44 in peak · freestanding

Buy the floor. The Grand Mesa 2 lists an 85 x 57 in floor, and that 57 in width is the number to notice: it is 7 in wider than the Crane Creek and Stormbreak, wide enough for two 25-in pads with room between them. Add a listed 44 in peak, the tallest in this guide, and the Grand Mesa is the budget tent two adults can sit up in side by side. Kelty lists 4 lb 1 oz trail and 4 lb 7 oz packed, which is a pound lighter than the two-door tents and within a pound of the Naturehike.

What $150 leaves out: a second door. The Grand Mesa has one D-door and one vestibule, so the sleeper on the far side climbs over at night. The 68D polyester fly and floor are durable and a little heavy, and the single-hub pole structure is simple rather than stiff in high wind. For a pair who camps below tree line on weekends, none of this will bother you. For a pair who wants their own door, the Crane Creek is $79 and a pound away.

Kelty's Quick Corners hold the poles in their grommets while you clip the body, which makes this a one-person pitch, and the Shark Mouth stuff sack opens wide enough that you can actually get the tent back in. Those are small things that decide whether a tent gets used. The Grand Mesa is freestanding, so it pitches on platforms and packed dirt; stake the vestibule and the fly corners and it is done. It is the tent we would hand a new backpacker with $150, and the one most of them would still be using three seasons later.

Listed weight
4 lb 1 oz trail / 4 lb 7 oz packed
Floor
30 sq ft (85 x 57 in, listed)
Peak height
44 in
Doors
1 door, 1 vestibule
Fabric
68D polyester floor and fly, seam taped
Poles
Aluminum pressfit, Quick Corners
Structure
Freestanding
Packed size
16 x 7 x 7 in (listed)
Price
about $150

What we like

  • Widest floor (57 in) and tallest peak (44 in) in the band
  • 4 lb 1 oz trail weight, lighter than both two-door tents
  • About $150, the cheapest here
  • Quick Corners make it a one-person pitch

Worth noting

  • One door, one vestibule
  • 68D polyester is heavier than premium nylon
  • Simple pole structure for calm-weather camps

Who should buy it: Buy the Grand Mesa 2 if $150 is the budget, if two people share it and one door is acceptable, or if floor width and headroom matter more than a second vestibule. It is the right first backpacking tent and a good permanent one for weekend pairs.

What we don't like: One door, one vestibule: the far sleeper climbs over. 68D polyester is durable but heavier than the flagship nylons. The simple pole structure is not the tent for exposed ridgelines in wind. Amazon's product-detail dimensions disagree with Kelty's listed 85 x 57 in; we use Kelty's figures.

Bottom line: The Grand Mesa 2 is the most tent per dollar in this band. Kelty lists 30 sq ft on an 85 x 57 in floor, the widest here, under a 44 in peak, the tallest here, at 4 lb 1 oz trail weight, lighter than both two-door tents, for about $150, the cheapest price here. Aluminum pressfit poles, Kelty's Quick Corners, color-coded clips, and taped seams. One door and one vestibule is the compromise, and for most pairs it is the right one.

02 · Best Two-Door Under $300

Best Two-Door
Marmot Crane Creek 2P

Marmot Crane Creek 2P

4.6about $229

Two D-doors, two vestibules, 32 sq ft, and 7000-series aluminum poles for about $229.

Field check: Listed 32 sq ft (86 x 50 in) · 43 in peak · 2 doors, 2 vestibules · 2,400 g on the Amazon listing

Two doors is the feature budget tents skip, and the one pairs miss most. The Crane Creek 2P gives each sleeper a D-shaped door and a vestibule, so nobody climbs over anybody and each person's pack and boots have their own covered space. Marmot lists 32 sq ft of interior on an 86 x 50 in floor under a 43 in peak, 7000-series aluminum poles, and a fully seam-taped polyester fly and floor. It has been in Marmot's line for years, carries 4,000-plus Amazon ratings at 4.6 stars, and behaves like a tent from a company that has made them since 1971.

The weight: Amazon lists 2,400 g, about 5 lb 5 oz. Marmot's own published trail and packed weights vary by version, so treat the number as approximate, but the Crane Creek is a 5-lb-class tent, a pound over the Grand Mesa and roughly 2 lb over the flagship tents. Split between two packs, that is 2.6 lb each, fine for weekends. Carried solo, it is the wrong tent.

Against the Stormbreak 2, the other two-door tent here, the Crane Creek is slightly lighter on the listed figures, $9 more, with a sq ft more of floor; the Stormbreak answers with 75D fabric throughout. Against the Grand Mesa, the Crane Creek is the tent you buy when the second door is non-negotiable and the $79 and the pound are not.

Listed weight
2,400 g (about 5 lb 5 oz), Amazon listing
Floor
32 sq ft (86 x 50 in, listed)
Peak height
43 in
Doors
2 D-doors, 2 vestibules
Fabric
Seam-taped polyester fly and floor
Poles
7000-series aluminum
Structure
Freestanding
Price
about $229

What we like

  • Two doors and two vestibules
  • 32 sq ft, the biggest floor in the band
  • 7000-series aluminum poles, taped seams
  • 4,000-plus ratings at 4.6 stars, years in the line

Worth noting

  • About 5 lb 5 oz; the heavy end of the band
  • About $229, the priciest here
  • Footprint sold separately

Who should buy it: Buy the Crane Creek 2P if two people share the tent regularly and each wants a door and a vestibule, if you want the biggest floor in the band, or if you want the Marmot name and warranty under $250. It is the right tent for couples who weekend below tree line.

What we don't like: About 5 lb 5 oz on the Amazon listing is a pound over the Grand Mesa and two over the flagships. At about $229 it is the most expensive tent here. Polyester fly and floor are durable, not light. A footprint is not included.

Bottom line: The Crane Creek 2P is the budget tent built for two people who are both tired. Two large D-doors, two vestibules, a listed 32 sq ft floor, the biggest here, and a 43 in peak, on 7000-series aluminum poles with a seam-taped polyester fly and floor. The Amazon listing puts it at 2,400 g, about 5 lb 5 oz, so it is the heavier of the two Kelty alternatives by about a pound, and at about $229 it costs $79 more. Both numbers buy the second door, and for a pair that is worth it.

03 · Lightest Under $300

Lightest
Naturehike Cloud Up Pro 2

Naturehike Cloud Up Pro 2

4.3about $159

The 3.5-to-4-lb two-layer tent that made packable budget shelters a category.

Field check: Listed about 3.5 to 4 lb packed (by version) · 20D two-layer · freestanding body · about $159

This is the tent that broke the price floor, and it is still the lightest thing under $300. The Cloud Up Pro 2 uses 20D nylon in a two-layer build, the same material class as the $500 tents, and lists a packed weight in the 3.5 to 4 lb range depending on the version on the listing. That is a pound under the Grand Mesa and roughly two under the Crane Creek and Stormbreak. The body pitches freestanding; the single vestibule stakes out. It is the one tent in this guide we would carry solo on a multi-day trip.

What the low price and weight cost: one door, a vestibule that needs a stake, simpler pole and clip detailing than Kelty or Marmot, and a floor (about 83 x 49 in listed) that is the narrowest here. Long-term durability at heavy use is the open question with any budget shelter; inspect seams and hardware each season. And check the live listing for which version you are buying, because weights and floor dimensions differ between Cloud Up generations.

Our brand judgment, restated: Naturehike is a real company (founded 2010, full catalogue, global retail distribution beyond Amazon) and the Cloud Up is its most proven product. It sits in this guide as a budget tent, not as a flagship. Against the Grand Mesa at about the same price, the Naturehike is lighter and narrower; the Kelty is wider, taller, and from a brand with a warranty history. Pick by your trips: longer and lighter, Naturehike; shorter and roomier, Kelty.

Listed weight
about 3.5 to 4 lb packed (varies by version)
Floor
about 83 x 49 in (listed)
Peak height
about 40 in
Doors
1 door, 1 staked vestibule
Fabric
20D nylon, two-layer
Poles
Aluminum
Structure
Freestanding body, staked vestibule
Price
about $159

What we like

  • Lightest in the band by a pound or more
  • 20D two-layer build, flagship-class material
  • Freestanding body
  • The most proven budget tent line sold

Worth noting

  • One door, staked vestibule
  • Narrowest floor here, about 49 in
  • Specs vary by version; read the listing

Who should buy it: Buy the Cloud Up Pro 2 if weight leads your priorities under $300, if you solo in a two-person tent, or if your trips run three or more days where a pound compounds. It is the budget tent closest to the flagship recipe.

What we don't like: One door and a staked vestibule. The narrowest floor here at about 49 in. Detailing and hardware are a tier below Kelty and Marmot. Listed weight and dimensions vary by version, so read the live listing. Long-term heavy-use durability is the standing budget question.

Bottom line: The Cloud Up Pro 2 is the lightest tent in this band by a pound or more, listed in the 3.5 to 4 lb range depending on version, with 20D fabric and a two-layer build that is closer to the flagship recipe than anything else here. It is a Tier B brand we judged and kept: a real company with a decade-plus in market and one of the largest owner bases in budget shelters. Buy it for longer trips where the Kelty and Marmot weights start to matter, and accept a single door, a staked vestibule, and simpler detailing.

04 · Fastest Pitch Under $300

Fastest Pitch
Kelty Late Start 2

Kelty Late Start 2

4.2about $160

Pre-bent poles and a near-foolproof pitch for camps made in the dark, at 4 lb 8 oz packed.

Field check: Listed 4 lb 8 oz packed · about 29 sq ft · 40 in peak · pre-bent poles · about $160

Named for its whole reason to exist. The Late Start 2 is built around a pitch that works when you cannot see: pre-bent aluminum poles that self-locate in Kelty's Quick Corners, color-coded clips, and a fly that goes on the same way every time. Kelty lists 4 lb 8 oz packed, about 29 sq ft, and a 40 in peak, with one door and one vestibule. It is the tent for the Friday-night trailhead.

Late Start or Grand Mesa: same brand, same price bracket, same door count. The Grand Mesa has a wider listed floor (57 in wide, 30 sq ft against about 29), a taller peak (44 in against 40), and a lower listed trail weight. The Late Start has the faster, simpler pitch. If you are usually setting up camp with daylight to spare, the Grand Mesa is the better tent for the same money. If you are usually setting up by headlamp, the Late Start earns its name.

Like every tent in this band it is polyester, taped, and freestanding, and like its sibling it is not chasing grams. What it offers that nothing else here does is a pitch you will not have to relearn after a month off, which is worth more than it sounds to occasional backpackers.

Listed weight
4 lb 8 oz packed
Floor
about 29 sq ft
Peak height
40 in
Doors
1 door, 1 vestibule
Fabric
Polyester, seam taped
Poles
Pre-bent aluminum, Quick Corners
Structure
Freestanding
Price
about $160

What we like

  • Fastest, simplest pitch in the band
  • Pre-bent poles pitch in fading light
  • Heritage Kelty brand and warranty
  • About $160

Worth noting

  • Less floor and headroom than the Grand Mesa
  • One door
  • Mid-pack weight

Who should buy it: Buy the Late Start 2 if your trips begin after work and camp is made at dusk, if you want the simplest pitch in the band, or if you are a first-timer who wants a heritage brand and a fast setup over floor area.

What we don't like: Smaller floor and lower peak than the Grand Mesa for about $10 more. 4 lb 8 oz packed is mid-pack here. One door, one vestibule. Not an ultralight, and not trying to be.

Bottom line: The Late Start 2 is the Grand Mesa's sibling with a different thesis: pitch speed. Kelty's pre-bent poles and Quick Corners get it up in under three minutes in fading light, the listed 4 lb 8 oz packed weight is a touch heavier than the Grand Mesa, the floor is a touch smaller at about 29 sq ft, and the peak is 40 in. It costs about $10 more. Buy it over the Grand Mesa only if after-work departures and dusk arrivals are the pattern of your trips; otherwise the Grand Mesa's extra floor and headroom win.

05 · Toughest Under $300

Toughest
The North Face Stormbreak 2

The North Face Stormbreak 2

4.5about $220

75D polyester everywhere, two doors, 30.56 sq ft, and a listed 5 lb 14 oz that tells you why.

Field check: Listed 5 lb 5 oz trail / 5 lb 14.2 oz total · 30.56 sq ft (87 x 50 in) · 43 in peak · 75D polyester, 2 doors

Heavy fabric is a feature when the floor is rock. The Stormbreak 2 is one of the few tents under $300 that lists 75D polyester for the floor, the fly, and the canopy, and 75D is roughly four to five times the denier of the flagship tents' 15D to 20D nylon. That is why it weighs a listed 5 lb 14.2 oz total, and it is also why it shrugs off the campsite abuse that punctures ultralight floors. Two large doors, two vestibules with twin zips, mesh pockets that hold the rolled doors open, and high-low vents round it out.

Who this is for: pairs who camp on rock and roots, families, anyone who brings a dog with claws, and anyone who will loan the tent to beginners. The 87 x 50 in floor fits two 25-in pads exactly. The 43 in peak sits up. It has 2,500-plus Amazon ratings at 4.6 stars and has been in The North Face line for years. It is a durable, well-made, heavy tent, and The North Face does not pretend otherwise: they publish a 3 lb 14 oz fastpack weight for fly-and-footprint pitching, which is another way of saying the full tent is nearly six pounds.

Against the Crane Creek, the Stormbreak is $9 cheaper, a touch heavier on the listed figures, a square foot smaller, and tougher. Against everything else here it is the tent to buy when durability outranks weight. For a weekend pair whose approach is two miles, that is a perfectly good set of priorities.

Listed weight
5 lb 5 oz trail / 5 lb 14.2 oz total / 3 lb 14.1 oz fastpack
Floor
30.56 sq ft (87 x 50 in, listed)
Peak height
43 in
Doors
2 doors, 2 twin-zip vestibules
Fabric
75D polyester taffeta canopy, fly, and floor; 40D mesh
Structure
Freestanding
Finish
Non-PFC DWR, no flame-retardant coating (listed)
Price
about $220

What we like

  • 75D polyester floor, fly, and canopy
  • Two doors, two vestibules
  • 2,500-plus ratings at 4.6 stars
  • The tent to loan, drag, and abuse

Worth noting

  • Listed 5 lb 14.2 oz total, heaviest here
  • Bulky packed
  • Footprint sold separately

Who should buy it: Buy the Stormbreak 2 if your camps are rocky, your tent partners include dogs or children, or you want a tent that survives loaning out. It is the right tent for short approaches and hard use.

What we don't like: Listed 5 lb 14.2 oz total is the heaviest tent in this guide and nearly double the flagships. Bulky packed. 75D polyester is tough, not light. Footprint sold separately. Not a tent for long solo miles under any circumstances.

Bottom line: The Stormbreak 2 is the tent in this band built for abuse. The North Face lists 75D polyester taffeta for canopy, fly, and floor, fully seam taped, with two doors, two twin-zip vestibules, a 30.56 sq ft floor, and a 43 in peak. It also lists 5 lb 14.2 oz total and 5 lb 5 oz trail, the heaviest here, and that is the whole trade: fabric you can drag across granite for a pound over the Crane Creek. Buy it for rocky camps, dogs, kids, and loaner duty. Do not carry it far.

More gear worth comparing

Beyond this guide: the highest-rated gear across every category and budget, with a live price check on each.

Osprey Talon 22

Daypack

Osprey Talon 22

22 L · ~$160

Check price
Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP

Hiking Boot

Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP

waterproof mid · ~$150

Check price
Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2

Ultralight Tent

Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2

3 lb listed · ~$550

Check price
Kelty Cosmic Down 20

Sleeping Bag

Kelty Cosmic Down 20

550-fill listed · ~$190

Check price
Therm-a-Rest NeoAir XLite NXT

Sleeping Pad

Therm-a-Rest NeoAir XLite NXT

R 4.5 listed · ~$175

Check price
Sawyer Squeeze

Water Filter

Sawyer Squeeze

~3 oz listed · ~$45

Check price

As an Amazon Associate we may earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.

Quick shop: every pick

Skip the scroll — the whole lineup, with a live price check on each.

  1. Kelty Grand Mesa 2Best Overall Under $300Kelty · about $150Check price →
  2. Marmot Crane Creek 2PBest Two-Door Under $300Marmot · about $229Check price →
  3. Naturehike Cloud Up Pro 2Lightest Under $300Naturehike · about $159Check price →
  4. Kelty Late Start 2Fastest Pitch Under $300Kelty · about $160Check price →
  5. The North Face Stormbreak 2Toughest Under $300The North Face · about $220Check price →

How we chose

What we did: we set a hard ceiling of $300 live Amazon price, restricted the field to two-person tents with aluminum poles, taped seams, and a full fly from brands with a real tent-making history (Kelty, Marmot, The North Face, and Naturehike, which we judged Tier B and kept in July 2026), pulled each maker's listed weight, floor, peak, door count, and fabric from the live listings, and re-verified every ASIN and price on August 23, 2026. We then read long-term owner reports for the budget-tent failure modes: pole splinter, fly leak at the seams, zipper death, and floor wet-through.

What we did not do: we did not weigh these tents, pitch them side by side in a storm, or run hydrostatic tests. Listed figures read as listed; where a maker publishes one weight we say which one. Prices move with sales and colorways, and a tent at $229 today may be $199 next month.

How we rank: floor and headroom per dollar first, then weight, then doors. Our Pick is the tent we would tell a friend with $150 to buy.

Key terms

Denier (D)
The thickness of the yarn in a fabric; higher is heavier and tougher. Budget tents use 68D to 75D polyester; flagship tents use 15D to 20D nylon. The difference is most of the weight gap between this guide and the main tent guide.
Trail weight vs packed weight
Trail or minimum weight counts body, fly, and poles; packed weight adds stakes, guylines, and sacks. The gap is 6 to 10 oz. Compare the same figure across tents.
Freestanding
A tent that stands on its own pole structure without stakes. Every tent here is freestanding, though all need stakes for the fly and vestibule in wind.
Vestibule
The covered area under the fly outside the door, for packs and boots. Two-door tents have two; that is the main thing the Crane Creek and Stormbreak buy over the Keltys.

Questions, answered

What is the best 2-person backpacking tent under $300?

The Kelty Grand Mesa 2 at about $150: listed 4 lb 1 oz trail weight, a 30 sq ft floor that is 57 in wide, a 44 in peak, aluminum poles, and a freestanding pitch. If two doors matter, the Marmot Crane Creek 2P at about $229 is the pick.

What is the lightest backpacking tent under $300?

The Naturehike Cloud Up Pro 2 at about $159, listed in the 3.5 to 4 lb packed range depending on version. It is the only tent in this guide under 4 lb and the one to carry solo on longer trips.

Is a $150 backpacking tent good enough?

Yes, for pairs and weekenders. The Kelty Grand Mesa 2 and Naturehike Cloud Up Pro 2 both have aluminum poles, taped seams, and full flies. What you give up against a $550 tent is about two pounds and refinement, not weather protection.

How much should a budget backpacking tent weigh?

Expect 4 to 6 lb for a two-person tent under $300, against 2.5 to 3.5 lb for flagship tents. Split between two hikers that is 2 to 3 lb each, which is a reasonable weekend load.

Is the MSR Elixir 2 worth it over the Marmot Crane Creek 2P?

Only if you specifically want MSR's pole and warranty pedigree. At about $340 the Elixir 2 is over this guide's $300 line, and it is not lighter than the Crane Creek; both are 5-lb-class two-door tents. The $110 difference buys a name, not a pound.

Do I need a footprint for a budget tent?

Less than for an ultralight tent. 68D and 75D polyester floors are far more puncture-resistant than 15D nylon. On granite or desert a footprint still helps; on duff and grass it is optional. None of these tents includes one.

Are budget tents waterproof?

The ones here are: every tent in this guide has a full-coverage fly and factory-taped seams. The budget tents that leak are the ones with partial flies or untaped seams, which is why both are on our skip list.